Thursday, September 15, 2005

Myth of Localism Hinders School Funding

Will the Texas Supreme Court fix the school funding mess that legislators have thrown in the towel on resolving?

The state’s high court should issue a decision soon on state district judge John Dietz’s ruling that Texas’s methods of funding public education is unconstitutional because it fails to meet the constitution’s mandate “to establish and make suitable provision for the support and maintenance of an efficient system of public free schools.”  Dietz’s decision stated that not only was the state not properly funding schools, but local districts are hobbled because of a legislative cap on what they could tax property holders.

Although Governor Rick Perry and House Speaker Tom Craddick unsuccessfully asked lawmakers this summer to formulate a plan that would effectively solve the state’s funding problem.  Perhaps lawmakers adopted a “wait and see” attitude: Let the high court rule and then react to that decision.  Maybe the various plans were too controversial to reach a consensus.  I suggest the real obstacle to solving the problem of school funding is the “Myth of Localism” that is so ingrained in Texan’s minds that it blinds lawmakers and the public to any realistic solution.

First, the Myth of Localism has convinced us that we should pay for public education with local property taxes.  The problem is, as real estate agents like to say, location.  Not all property is equal thus neither can schools expect to raise the equitable funds in poor districts as they can in wealthy districts.  An accident of birth should not condemn a child to a substandard education.  In the days when people largely remained in their home town, maybe a “local” education was all anyone needed.  World War II showed us that students must be educationally prepared at least to some national baseline in order to compete, whether in a national war effort or in our increasingly global economy.

Second, the Myth of Localism has deluded us into believing that local control of the schools is incompatible with a state-wide system of taxation.  This belief reaches back to the days of Reconstruction.  In 1876, the drafters of our present state constitution represented a public who resented any tax to pay for state improvements, much less to educate poor white or minority students.  Instead of allowing the state to set a standard tax rate, or property valuation, Redeemers hoped to return to the pre-Civil War practice of reporting (or rather under-reporting) their own taxes every year.  Accordingly, the state constitution prohibits a state-wide tax.  This prohibition in effect allowed local leaders to undervalue their own property, thus limiting the amount of money for local schools, and thereby limiting education to those who they deemed fit for schooling.

Our devotion to the Myth of Localism has blinded us to the fact that our educational expectations are national, not local.  From standardized achievement exams, whose results play an important role in determining funding, to textbooks, to national curriculum standards, to federal programs and initiatives like No Child Left Behind, our “local” schools really strive to prepare our students equally for national standards.  Education is a state issue and responsibility. We must eliminate our reliance on local property taxes to pay for education, and have state funding.

We deceived ourselves into believing that localism is somehow democratic.  We must look past this myth. True democratic education will fulfill the framers of the Texas constitution intent to provide for an efficient system of education for all Texas children.

No comments: