Gene Preuss on Teaching History
Online information about education and history, and mixing the two together!
Friday, August 03, 2018
Friday, December 26, 2014
A Brief History Lesson on the Long Civil Rights Movement
Back in October 2010, I was in Lubbock and my wife asked me to travel to a small town to take some pictures of family graves for a research project she was working in.
I followed her directions to the West Texas community of Meadow, and quickly found the Meadow Cemetery.
The Meadow Cemetery is a mile out of town, but not entirely isolated. It is surrounded by cotton fields, and a few homes. But when I arrived there, it was fairly lonely. The only other person there was Mr. Perez, the caretaker, an older Hispanic fellow who was concerned that when I was not supposed to drive around the cemetery looking at headstones. He explained that the what I had supposed were "roads", were actually paths. The problem, he stated, was there were unmarked graves across the cemetery, and I might be driving over those graves, and if they collapsed, it would be real trouble.
I followed her directions to the West Texas community of Meadow, and quickly found the Meadow Cemetery.The Meadow Cemetery is a mile out of town, but not entirely isolated. It is surrounded by cotton fields, and a few homes. But when I arrived there, it was fairly lonely. The only other person there was Mr. Perez, the caretaker, an older Hispanic fellow who was concerned that when I was not supposed to drive around the cemetery looking at headstones. He explained that the what I had supposed were "roads", were actually paths. The problem, he stated, was there were unmarked graves across the cemetery, and I might be driving over those graves, and if they collapsed, it would be real trouble.
He asked who I was looking for, and then helped me locate the various headstones on my list. The primary grave I needed was located in the back of the cemetery. He pointed it out, and said that behind the grave was indeed another road around the cemetery.
He told me he had been caretaker for a number of years, and said that the previous caretaker had tried to plot all of the graves, those marked and those unmarked. He said he was a bit of a historian, like me.
He pointed to the newer part of the cemetery across the road where there is a building, and said that he found a cemetery plat inside which had the names of the plot owners, and written in large letters on the side "No Niggers! No Meskins!" He said he gave the map to the local museum, and I could go there and see it for myself.
The town and the cemetery were segregated. Of course this made sense to me, as a historian, that many West Texas communities were segregated in the past. Many of these communities were founded in the 1920s, when white settlers came to the Southern Plains, and there were few minority settlers.
The road in the back part of the cemetery, he further explained, separated the white graves from the Mexican graves. They did allow Mexican-American burials, but on the other side of the road--still, there were no African Americans buried in the cemetery.
He then told me that his father and brother were the first Mexican-Americans buried in the cemetery proper, not "on the other side." He said he bought the plots when his father was near death for $500. When the community found out that the plots were for Mexican-Americans, they offered him $5,000 to buy the plots back, but he refused.
I suspected this probably happened in the 1950s or 1960s, soon after Mexican-Americans had began claiming equal rights and protections. I often teach about the 1948 case Delgado v. Bastrop, and the 1954 Supreme Court case Hernandez v. Texas. Both cases challenged the segregation of Mexican-Americans, in public schools and in jury selections (respectively) and along with other cases that followed began opening doors previously closed to the Texas Mexican-American community.
When I asked him if this happened in the 60s, he chuckled. I thought maybe as late as the 70s? He said, "No, it happened in 2000!" I was dumbfounded. As a historian I'm accustomed to discuss segregation issues in the past, but had not anticipated a recent example. The Civil Rights Era and its struggle against discrimination and segregation is a topic for the mid-20th century, not the 21st century, after all. Many students in my history classes think it ended with Martin Luther King, the NAACP, Cesar Chavez, and LULAC.
Sadly, it still occurs, long after the laws of our land have changed, and I should not be surprised. My wife and I went back to the cemetery around Christmas 2014. Now, of course more Mexican-American graves are "in" the cemetery, not just beyond the road that encircles the cemetary. Surely, someone had to be the first, and I'm still amazed that I would happen to meet a person who through determination, and refusing to bow to community practice was the person who broke the "color barrier" in this tiny West Texas community.
His story remains as an example of the lingering customs and practices that defy the limits of the law. It also demonstrates that the civil rights battles of the 1960s did not end fifty years ago, but continues today.
Wednesday, November 05, 2008
Barack Obama and the End of African American History?
I think we can all agree that yesterday we witnessed an historic election. For the first time in our nation’s democracy we overcame questions of gender and race in our presidential candidates. In 1992, neoconservative philosopher and economist Francis Fukuyama gained notoriety with his essay, “The End of History,” and later book THE END OF HISTORY AND THE LAST MAN, where he carried forward Hegel and Marx’s idea that history was the progression of political struggle. Fukuyama posited that Western liberal democracy marked the utopia of political thought and signaled the end of this progression and thus the end of history.
When teaching the history of minority groups, and especially African Americans, it’s often said that the words Thomas Jefferson put to velum in the Declaration of Independence, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness,” was not something set in stone, but a goal. At the Lincoln Memorial, Martin Luther King, Jr., said he dreamed that “one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed”. So, to borrow from Fukuyama’s scaffolding, I’d like to ask what the election of Barack Obama will mean to the future of African American history. If African American history has told of the struggle to achieve equity in American society, did we reach that point in yesterday’s election?
Will the election change the way our students think about African-American history? Will it change how we teach the subject? Does this mean that we’ve moved past the multicultural into a fully post-ethnic society, or perhaps that we’ve even transcended the post-ethnic? Or is race even the issue? Did Americans turn out to elect the “first African American” president, or was this a rejection of the Reagan-era supply-side conservative Republicanism that George W. Bush claimed as his political heritage? Or was it a reaction against the economic downturn that is affecting the nation? If voters flocked to Obama because he is black that is one thing, but it says something completely different if he won because he was the Democratic nominee. Was his nomination and election a result of the “novelty” of an African-American candidate?
As I watched Obama’s election celebration last night, and saw John Lewis, Jesse Jackson, and heard about 106 year-old Ann Nixon Cooper, I thought of the changes African Americans have seen in the past century, the past 50 years, and the past decade. I remember watching public service announcements for the United Negro College Fund on television emphasize the phrase, “The mind is a terrible thing to waste.” I was especially moved by a grandfather putting his grandson on a school bus. The older man encouraged the younger boy to study and do well in school and one day he might become a doctor. The young boy looked up at his grandfather and asked why he didn’t go to college. Of course, the unspoken message was that race and poverty prevented the grandfather from realizing his dreams. Will Obama’s election affect the question of the future of Affirmative Action? Does his election mean that we’ve moved beyond race as a determining issue, much as we look to John Kennedy’s election as Americans’ willingness to overlook his Catholicism? Have we now moved beyond race as an issue? How will students consider race relations in American history from now on? One African American woman said last night that she went to the polls with her grandchildren and could now honestly tell them that anyone of them could grow up to be president. Did the election make manifest the goals of MLK’s Dream, and the struggles of the Civil Rights Movement?
When teaching the history of minority groups, and especially African Americans, it’s often said that the words Thomas Jefferson put to velum in the Declaration of Independence, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness,” was not something set in stone, but a goal. At the Lincoln Memorial, Martin Luther King, Jr., said he dreamed that “one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed”. So, to borrow from Fukuyama’s scaffolding, I’d like to ask what the election of Barack Obama will mean to the future of African American history. If African American history has told of the struggle to achieve equity in American society, did we reach that point in yesterday’s election?
Will the election change the way our students think about African-American history? Will it change how we teach the subject? Does this mean that we’ve moved past the multicultural into a fully post-ethnic society, or perhaps that we’ve even transcended the post-ethnic? Or is race even the issue? Did Americans turn out to elect the “first African American” president, or was this a rejection of the Reagan-era supply-side conservative Republicanism that George W. Bush claimed as his political heritage? Or was it a reaction against the economic downturn that is affecting the nation? If voters flocked to Obama because he is black that is one thing, but it says something completely different if he won because he was the Democratic nominee. Was his nomination and election a result of the “novelty” of an African-American candidate?
As I watched Obama’s election celebration last night, and saw John Lewis, Jesse Jackson, and heard about 106 year-old Ann Nixon Cooper, I thought of the changes African Americans have seen in the past century, the past 50 years, and the past decade. I remember watching public service announcements for the United Negro College Fund on television emphasize the phrase, “The mind is a terrible thing to waste.” I was especially moved by a grandfather putting his grandson on a school bus. The older man encouraged the younger boy to study and do well in school and one day he might become a doctor. The young boy looked up at his grandfather and asked why he didn’t go to college. Of course, the unspoken message was that race and poverty prevented the grandfather from realizing his dreams. Will Obama’s election affect the question of the future of Affirmative Action? Does his election mean that we’ve moved beyond race as a determining issue, much as we look to John Kennedy’s election as Americans’ willingness to overlook his Catholicism? Have we now moved beyond race as an issue? How will students consider race relations in American history from now on? One African American woman said last night that she went to the polls with her grandchildren and could now honestly tell them that anyone of them could grow up to be president. Did the election make manifest the goals of MLK’s Dream, and the struggles of the Civil Rights Movement?
Tuesday, November 04, 2008
The US Makes History
We have just heard the concession speech by Sen. John McCain who ran for president of the US. I'm waiting to hear the acceptance speech by Sen. Barack Obama. For the first time in US history, we will have an African American president. This is a new era in politics in the US. A New period of Race Relations. A New Day is Dawning. What the future holds one can only imagine. I never thought I'd live to see this happen. I thought racism was too entrenched in American society and culture. I'm happily eating my words. I certainly don't think that there will be a new atmosphere tomorrow. I think racism is still alive and well, but this is something!
Monday, June 30, 2008
Buffalo Soldier Hill, NM
When Oscar Robinson, director of University Personnel Services at Eastern New Mexico University, in Portales, NM, learned about the site, he went to work to change the name. Today, a New Mexico state historic marker sits on FM 114, just inside the Texas/New Mexico state line and tells the story of the Buffalo Soldier Tragedy of 1877 (see my other post).
The photo is of Mr. Robinson, along with members of the Texas Parks and Wildlife Buffalo Soldier Living History Program, honoring the sacrifice of the four young troopers who died during a search for a Comanche raiding party.
Buffalo Soldier Tragedy
The African-American soldiers, under the command of Capt. Nicholas Nolan, became lost while searching for a rogue band of Comanche. They were without water for 86 hours on the dry, blistering Staked Plains. Most thought they had died, and the incident drew national attention. Slowly, the remains of the scouting party made their way back to Fort Concho in San Angelo, and told the story. A few years ago, Paul Carlson wrote a book on the incident, The Buffalo Soldier Tragedy of 1877.
Monday, June 09, 2008
Early Houston
Francis Lubbock discusses the Allen Brothers, founders of the mighty city of Houston:
" These thorough going business men had tried to purchase the site of old Harrisburg for the purpose of founding a town but failing in this they bought the Parott league a few miles above on Buffalo Bayou. On this league at the head of navigation they had laid out the new town of Houston named in honor of the President of the Republic. By their enterprise and influence they had succeeded in getting the seat of government removed to that place to remain until 1840 These brothers AC and JK had been in Texas three or four years and three other brothers arrived in Houston soon after its location all of them good and prominent citizens. JK Allen was a very bright quick man with much magic about him and well calculated to enthuse the young. AC was more taciturn and settled he was a married man with his family then in Nacogdoches. The former died very soon after locating the place the latter lived many years thereafter. The Allens encouraged me to go with them taking the goods still on hand to open a house in the town of Houston. We took a small steamer called the Laura owned by McKinney & Williams. ... We made a safe run into Galveston Bay where we lay aground several days and thence up the bay and Buffalo Bayou arriving at Harrisburg without difficulty. The navigation after entering the bayou was good with plenty of water and breadth until we reached this place. Here we were cordially welcomed by the people of the village among them the Birdsalls Wilsons Riohardsons and Harrises. The town was called Harrisburg as was also the county after the last named family. Subsequently the name of the county was changed to Harris by law. ... No boat had ever been above this place and we were three days making the distance to Houston only six miles by the dirt road but twelve by the bayou. The slow time was in consequence of the obstructions we were compelled to remove as we progressed. We had to rig what were called Spanish windlasses on the shore to heave the logs and snags out of our way the passengers all working faithfully. All hands on board would get out on the shore and cutting down a tree would make of it a windlass by boring holes in it and placing it upon a support and throwing a bight of rope around it secure one end to a tree in the rear and the other to the snags or fallen trees in the water. Then by means of the capstan bars we would turn the improvised capstan on land and draw from the track of our steamer the obstructions. Capitalist, dignified judge, military heroes, young merchant in fine clothes from the dressiest city in the United States, all lent a helping hand. It being necessary to lie by at night in the evenings we had a good time dancing and frolicking with the settlers on the shore who were delighted to see newcomers from the States. Just before reaching our destination a party of us becoming weary of the steamer took a yawl and concluded we would bunt for the city. So little evidence could we see of a landing that we passed by the site and run into White Oak Bayou only realizing that we must have passed the city when we struck in the brush. We then backed down the bayou and by close observation discovered a road or street laid off from the water's edge. Upon landing we found stakes and footprints indicating that we were in the town tract. This was about the first of January 1837 when I discovered Houston. For though I did not accompany Columbus when he discovered America as is asserted I certainly was in at the discovery of Houston the Laura being the first steamer that ever reached her landing. Wharves were not in Texas. A few tents were located not far away one large one was used as a saloon. Several small houses were in the course of erection. .
Six decades in Texas or, Memoirs of Francis Richard Lubbock, governor of Texas in war time, 1861-63. A personal experience in business, war, and politics By Francis Richard Lubbock, Cadwell Walton Raines, ed. (Austin: Ben C. Jones & Co., 1900) page 45-46
" These thorough going business men had tried to purchase the site of old Harrisburg for the purpose of founding a town but failing in this they bought the Parott league a few miles above on Buffalo Bayou. On this league at the head of navigation they had laid out the new town of Houston named in honor of the President of the Republic. By their enterprise and influence they had succeeded in getting the seat of government removed to that place to remain until 1840 These brothers AC and JK had been in Texas three or four years and three other brothers arrived in Houston soon after its location all of them good and prominent citizens. JK Allen was a very bright quick man with much magic about him and well calculated to enthuse the young. AC was more taciturn and settled he was a married man with his family then in Nacogdoches. The former died very soon after locating the place the latter lived many years thereafter. The Allens encouraged me to go with them taking the goods still on hand to open a house in the town of Houston. We took a small steamer called the Laura owned by McKinney & Williams. ... We made a safe run into Galveston Bay where we lay aground several days and thence up the bay and Buffalo Bayou arriving at Harrisburg without difficulty. The navigation after entering the bayou was good with plenty of water and breadth until we reached this place. Here we were cordially welcomed by the people of the village among them the Birdsalls Wilsons Riohardsons and Harrises. The town was called Harrisburg as was also the county after the last named family. Subsequently the name of the county was changed to Harris by law. ... No boat had ever been above this place and we were three days making the distance to Houston only six miles by the dirt road but twelve by the bayou. The slow time was in consequence of the obstructions we were compelled to remove as we progressed. We had to rig what were called Spanish windlasses on the shore to heave the logs and snags out of our way the passengers all working faithfully. All hands on board would get out on the shore and cutting down a tree would make of it a windlass by boring holes in it and placing it upon a support and throwing a bight of rope around it secure one end to a tree in the rear and the other to the snags or fallen trees in the water. Then by means of the capstan bars we would turn the improvised capstan on land and draw from the track of our steamer the obstructions. Capitalist, dignified judge, military heroes, young merchant in fine clothes from the dressiest city in the United States, all lent a helping hand. It being necessary to lie by at night in the evenings we had a good time dancing and frolicking with the settlers on the shore who were delighted to see newcomers from the States. Just before reaching our destination a party of us becoming weary of the steamer took a yawl and concluded we would bunt for the city. So little evidence could we see of a landing that we passed by the site and run into White Oak Bayou only realizing that we must have passed the city when we struck in the brush. We then backed down the bayou and by close observation discovered a road or street laid off from the water's edge. Upon landing we found stakes and footprints indicating that we were in the town tract. This was about the first of January 1837 when I discovered Houston. For though I did not accompany Columbus when he discovered America as is asserted I certainly was in at the discovery of Houston the Laura being the first steamer that ever reached her landing. Wharves were not in Texas. A few tents were located not far away one large one was used as a saloon. Several small houses were in the course of erection. .
Six decades in Texas or, Memoirs of Francis Richard Lubbock, governor of Texas in war time, 1861-63. A personal experience in business, war, and politics By Francis Richard Lubbock, Cadwell Walton Raines, ed. (Austin: Ben C. Jones & Co., 1900) page 45-46
Damn Carpetbaggers!
When the Moore administration took office, its first act was to extend the city limits, which to that time had been the Bayou on the north, Walker street on the south, Bagby street on the west and Caroline on the east. The limits were extended so as to embrace nine square miles. This was done in order to increase the taxable area and to include within the city limits many citizens who had build residences just beyond the old city lines. The nine-mile area was maintained many years, or until the city fell in the hands of the "Carpet-beg" Republicans appointed by E. J. Davis during reconstruction days. These found it necessary, in order to create more plunder, to increase the taxable area, so they extended the limits so as to embrace twenty-five square miles. When the Carpet-baggers were turned out of office by the home people who had regained control of affairs, the limits were reduced to nine square miles. That was in 1874, and until 1903 no change was made. By that time the city had so extended beyond its limits that an increase was demanded in justice and fairness to all, so the area was fixed at sixteen square miles. (p.11)
Dr. Samuel Oliver Young, A Thumb-Nail History of the City of Houston, Texas: From Its Founding in 1836 to the Year 1912 (Houston: Rein & Sons: 1912).
Dr. Samuel Oliver Young, A Thumb-Nail History of the City of Houston, Texas: From Its Founding in 1836 to the Year 1912 (Houston: Rein & Sons: 1912).
Wednesday, March 05, 2008
What is a “Culture of Evidence”?
I'm directing the Achieving the Dream grant initiative at the University of Houston-Downtown. A major requirement is to build a "culture of evidence." This is a statement on what this means:
The Achieving the Dream initiative seeks to develop strategies that will increase student success. For UHD that means that students will continue to enroll from one semester to the next, making grades of C or better, until they graduate from UHD.
In order to accomplish these goals, we will create a “culture of evidence” to evaluate the strategies. What this means is that in each of our strategies, expanding our College Success Program courses, establish peer tutoring for statistics courses, and faculty development. A “culture of evidence” means that we will made data-based decisions.
The national Achieving the Dream “framing paper” states:
This plays a larger role at UHD. We, as a university, are accredited by the Southern Association of Schools and Colleges (SACS). Accreditation is very important to an institution of higher education, because it is a statement that our institution and educational programs are following accepted standards. In short, it is a “stamp of approval.” Colleges and universities undergo a regular review every 10 years, and then are required to do regular follow ups in between. In the past few years, our accrediting agencies have placed more and more emphasis on “data-based” decisions, regular evaluation of degree programs, and creating a “culture of evidence” within the university. The faculty, staff, and administration at UHD are currently working very hard to prepare one of our regular reports to SACS, and to demonstrate how we are building a culture of evidence to evaluate our programs, so what we’re doing on a limited basis with the Achieving the Dream initiative on a few student success strategies, the university is also doing on a much larger basis.
Students should take this all very seriously because these efforts are to build a better UHD, something that we can all be proud of, whether we’re talking about a professor, custodian, librarian, college dean or student…we should all be working together to make UHD an institution we can be proud of.
The Achieving the Dream initiative seeks to develop strategies that will increase student success. For UHD that means that students will continue to enroll from one semester to the next, making grades of C or better, until they graduate from UHD.
In order to accomplish these goals, we will create a “culture of evidence” to evaluate the strategies. What this means is that in each of our strategies, expanding our College Success Program courses, establish peer tutoring for statistics courses, and faculty development. A “culture of evidence” means that we will made data-based decisions.
The national Achieving the Dream “framing paper” states:
“Institutions should make decisions and allocate resources based on evidence of what is working and what is not. A data-driven decision-making process is most effective when administrators, faculty and staff across the institution examine evidence and engage in frank discussions about outcomes for different student populations. The college then sets measurable goals for improvement and uses data to assess its progress.”This seems fairly straight forward, and common sense. Unfortunately, too often, people make decisions based on what they “think” will help. Maybe this is based upon experience or “anecdotal” evidence, but we do not often collect data and use it to evaluate our decisions. In other words, we must look at the evidence; see what it tells us about what we’re trying to do, and then see if we’re actually accomplishing what we set out to do. If the evidence demonstrates that it is successful, we can then expand on the program. If a particular strategy isn’t working, we can then adjust our efforts so we don’t keep wasting money and time on something that really isn’t working.
This plays a larger role at UHD. We, as a university, are accredited by the Southern Association of Schools and Colleges (SACS). Accreditation is very important to an institution of higher education, because it is a statement that our institution and educational programs are following accepted standards. In short, it is a “stamp of approval.” Colleges and universities undergo a regular review every 10 years, and then are required to do regular follow ups in between. In the past few years, our accrediting agencies have placed more and more emphasis on “data-based” decisions, regular evaluation of degree programs, and creating a “culture of evidence” within the university. The faculty, staff, and administration at UHD are currently working very hard to prepare one of our regular reports to SACS, and to demonstrate how we are building a culture of evidence to evaluate our programs, so what we’re doing on a limited basis with the Achieving the Dream initiative on a few student success strategies, the university is also doing on a much larger basis.
Students should take this all very seriously because these efforts are to build a better UHD, something that we can all be proud of, whether we’re talking about a professor, custodian, librarian, college dean or student…we should all be working together to make UHD an institution we can be proud of.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)